couple holding lactonic perfume santal foy - how to tell if a perfume is natural

How to Tell If a Perfume Is Natural: A Perfumer’s 8 Checks

By Kershen Teo, founder and perfumer of Prosody London

Knowing how to tell if a perfume is natural is harder than it should be. In the UK and EU there is no legal definition of “natural” for perfume or cosmetics, so the word on a bottle can mean almost anything. There is a voluntary standard, ISO 16128, which sets out a way to calculate how much of a product is of natural origin, but no brand is required to use it or to publish the result.

The short answer: the label alone rarely proves a perfume is natural. What it can do is raise questions. The checks below are the ones I would make as a perfumer: what the label shows, what it hides, and what to ask the brand when it doesn’t tell you.

  • Read past the word “Parfum”
  • Ask what the alcohol is made from
  • Ask about synthetic musks
  • Ask about phthalates
  • Separate “contains natural ingredients” from “100% natural”
  • Ask whether any synthetic materials are allowed at all
  • Look for specifics, not slogans
  • Wear it for a full day

1. Read past the word “Parfum”

On a UK or EU ingredient list, the whole fragrance blend can appear as one word: Parfum (or Fragrance). A perfume built from a few plant extracts and one built from dozens of synthetic musks, phthalates and other aroma chemicals can look identical at this point on the label.

Below Parfum you will usually see named fragrance allergens: linalool, limonene, geraniol, citral, coumarin and others. Every perfume sold in the UK and EU must list these once they pass set thresholds, natural or not, so the list on its own doesn’t prove anything. It is still worth reading. Many of these allergens occur naturally in essential oils and absolutes, so a natural perfume will often show a long list of them.

At Prosody London, each fragrance declares every allergen above the legal threshold, taken from our safety assessor’s allergen declaration for that formula. If a label shows Parfum and nothing else, and the brand won’t say more when asked, treat any “natural” claim with caution.

Santal Foy natural perfume by Prosody London, a man in a wheat field

2. Ask what the alcohol is made from

Most perfumes are made with ethanol that has been denatured (made undrinkable with an additive), and it appears on the label as Alcohol Denat. That name says nothing about where the ethanol came from or which denaturant was used.

Prosody London perfumes use organic grain alcohol, distilled from fermented grain. It still has to appear as Alcohol Denat. on the label, which is exactly why the question is worth asking: the label can’t tell you, but the brand can.


3. Ask about synthetic musks

Synthetic musks are some of the most widely used materials in conventional perfumery. They give a soft, skin-like note and help hold a fragrance on the skin, and they sit inside Parfum, so you won’t see them on the label. There are three main families:

  • Polycyclic musks, such as galaxolide and tonalide. They break down slowly and have been detected in rivers and wastewater, which is why they are studied as environmental contaminants.
  • Nitro musks, the oldest family. Most are now banned or restricted in EU cosmetics.
  • Macrocyclic musks, the family most modern perfumes rely on.

A fully natural perfume contains none of them. Its musky note comes from plants, usually ambrette seed, and its staying power from resins and balsams such as labdanum, benzoin, myrrh and frankincense. These evaporate slowly and hold the lighter materials on the skin, which is the job synthetic musks do in a conventional formula. If a “natural” perfume lists a musk note, it is fair to ask what it is made from.


4. Ask about phthalates

Phthalates are used in some fragrances as solvents and to help a scent last. The one most associated with perfume is diethyl phthalate (DEP). Several phthalates are banned in cosmetics in the EU and UK, but DEP is not among them and remains permitted. Like musks, it can sit inside Parfum without being named. For what regulators have said about phthalates, see our guide to endocrine disruptors in perfume.

Because the label won’t tell you, ask the brand directly whether the formula contains any phthalates. Prosody London perfumes contain none, and our safety assessor has confirmed this for every formula.


5. Separate “contains natural ingredients” from “100% natural”

A perfume can truthfully say it contains natural ingredients while being mostly synthetic. A little rose absolute or bergamot oil in a synthetic base is enough to support the claim. Words like “natural-inspired”, “nature-identical” and “clean” don’t help either. A nature-identical molecule is made in a laboratory to match one found in a plant, so it is synthetic, and “clean” has no regulatory definition at all.

Natural isolates are a different case, and worth understanding. An isolate is a single aroma molecule separated from a natural source, such as linalool taken from a plant oil. I use them to build accords for notes no single extract gives, such as hyacinth, jonquil or apricot, and every Prosody London natural perfume marks those accords with ° in its notes. Everything in our formulas, from the fixatives to the top notes, is plant-derived.


6. Ask whether any synthetic materials are allowed at all

Brands that call themselves natural don’t all draw the line in the same place. Some allow a small proportion of synthetic materials to smooth a blend, steady it from batch to batch or help it last. The reasons are real: natural materials vary with the harvest and the season, and that makes consistency harder.

At Prosody London I don’t use any. Every aromatic ingredient is plant-derived, which means more work at the formulation stage and more care in choosing materials that hold up from batch to batch. Neither approach is hidden from you if you ask, so ask: does the formula contain any synthetic aroma molecules, even in small amounts?

A man and a woman with Trevi Rose natural cologne by Prosody London

7. Look for specifics, not slogans

Any brand can call itself natural. Fewer can tell you which materials they use, how each one is extracted and what the formula leaves out. Specific answers are the best signal you will get.

How a material is extracted is part of that picture. Essential oils are usually steam-distilled or, for citrus peel, cold-pressed. Absolutes are extracted with a solvent, and CO2 extracts use pressurised carbon dioxide instead, which often keeps fresher top notes. Where a good CO2 extract exists, I often choose it over an absolute. Our ingredients page lists the materials in our olfactive palette, with the plant each one comes from and how it is extracted.

Every Prosody London formula is made to comply with the applicable IFRA Standards. Three questions are worth putting to any natural perfume brand: what standards do you formulate to, where do your materials come from, and what does your formula leave out? “Inspired by nature” or “free from harsh chemicals” doesn’t answer any of them.


8. Wear it for a full day

Your skin can’t prove a perfume is natural, but it can tell you a lot about how it is built. Natural perfumes tend to change noticeably as they wear. The citrus and green top notes go first, the flowers or spices of the heart follow, and woods, resins and balsams are what you smell hours later.

Natural materials are complex mixtures, too. Rose oil, for example, contains several hundred individual compounds, so a natural perfume often reads as more layered up close, and it tends to sit closer to the skin than a perfume built to project. Plenty of synthetic perfumes also evolve beautifully, so take this as one clue among several rather than a test.

A woman with Jacinth Jonquil natural perfume against an abstract painting

How to tell if a perfume is natural: the questions to ask

If the label leaves you unsure, ask the brand four things: what is the alcohol made from, does the formula contain any synthetic aroma molecules, does it contain synthetic musks, and does it contain phthalates? A brand that is fully natural can answer all four plainly.

For more on choosing, read our guide to shopping for natural perfume, or see how the best natural perfumes in the UK compare. To wear ours for a full day before choosing a bottle, build your own discovery set of four or six 2ml samples.

FOLLOW US

Similar Posts